Skip to content

0005 Call it layer, and take the numbers out of the provenance grade

Decision
0005
Status
Decided
Date
2026-10-12

The Korean version is authoritative. This page was translated by AI (Claude) and has not yet been checked by a person. 한국어 원문

Replaces items 6 and 7 of 0001

  • The organizational tiers are called “layer 0, layer 1, layer 2” instead of “0층, 1층, 2층”. Always the lowercase word layer and a number. Never shortened to “층”, “Layer” or “L1”.

  • The provenance grade (how far a record is from the original) is named with words instead of “L0 to L3”.

    Old name New name Ledger level value
    L0 original original
    L1 draft draft
    L2 confirmed confirmed
    L3 derived derived
  • “The authentic layer” (진본층) and “the interpretive layer” (해석층) stay as they are. Even though the Korean words end in 층 (“layer”), they are not layers in this sense. They divide the original from interpretations inside a record (terms from the common rules).

  • A new terms document, 05-Glossary, is created. It gathers the places where different projects call the same thing by different names, or use the same word with different meanings.

  • The file name 04-층.md stays as it is, because secretary issues and arkive documents point to it by that name. Only the title becomes “04 layer”.

Documents updated: working rules, 04-layer (v0.3), 03-manifest (v0.3), 05-Glossary (new).

  • Decision of the head of Nodeone (2026-10-12, passed on by the common rules session and confirmed again in this session): “Use layer, and find other terms for the provenance grades L0 to L3.”
  • Nodeone’s common rules already write “layer 0, 1, 2”. If only hgp said “0층”, the same thing would have two names.
  • “layer 1” and “L1” look almost the same. If both stay numbers, every sentence makes you work out whether “L1” means the store or a draft. There are only four provenance grades and words for them already exist (original, draft, confirmed, derived), so numbers are not needed.
  • windandflow also uses “L0 to L4” (membership levels) and “L3, L4” (technology bundles). L plus a number means different things in different places.
Option Why not chosen
Keep 0층, 1층, 2층 The names would split from the common rules. The head of Nodeone did not choose it
Give the provenance grade other letters plus numbers (G0 to G3, D0 to D3, and so on) Yet another set of symbols to memorize. The words already say what they mean
Also rename the ledger field level No code uses this field yet, so changing the values is enough. There is little reason to rename the field too
  • secretary: there is no level field yet. When it is added, use word values (item 3 of issue #67). If documents use notation such as “L1”, change it.
  • arkive: when level is added to transcription records, use word values (arkive to-do).
  • Common rules: the terms line in Nodeone’s common rules should point to 05-Glossary.

0 won.